In the digital retail landscape, few questions are as pivotal for brands as this: where will my products convert better—on Google Shopping or Amazon Ads? As a digital marketing agency working extensively across both ecosystems, we’ve found that the answer isn’t about choosing one over the other. Rather, it lies in understanding how each channel serves a fundamentally different role in the customer journey.

The Technical Foundations

Google Shopping

• Placement: Shopping placements within Google Search, Discover, YouTube, and the Display Network. Performance Max campaigns further extend reach across these surfaces.
• Feed-driven: Product data feeds (via Merchant Center) dictate ad eligibility and auction rank. Titles, GTINs, descriptions, and images must be carefully optimised to meet Google’s evolving standards.
• Auction model: Google’s auction balances bids with feed quality, ad relevance, and the expected impact of assets like images and pricing.

Amazon Ads

• Placement: Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, and Sponsored Display ads that appear across Amazon’s marketplace—on search results, competitor listings, and product detail pages.
• Intent advantage: Users on Amazon are there to buy. They’re already deep in the purchase funnel, making them some of the highest-intent shoppers online.
• Auction model: Amazon’s auction weighs historical performance—CTR, sales history, organic rank—alongside bid strength, often leading to faster iteration and clearer signals for advertisers.

Audience and Buyer Intent: A Key Difference

A critical distinction between the two platforms lies in buyer intent:

• Google Shopping reaches shoppers who are still comparing, researching, or discovering new brands. Users come to Google to explore—to read reviews, check prices, and consider alternatives. This discovery phase often involves multiple touchpoints and longer consideration cycles.
• Amazon Ads engage users who are already in a transactional mindset. When someone is on Amazon, they’re typically there to buy, not browse. That built-in intent drives consistently higher conversion rates for in-market products.

This difference is crucial. On Google, the path to purchase is often longer, requiring multiple engagements and trust-building. On Amazon, the journey from click to checkout is direct and conversion-focused.

Performance Metrics and Conversion Rates

Performance data typically highlights the conversion advantage of Amazon Ads:

Note: These figures are directional and can vary by vertical, competition, and campaign maturity.

Key Technical Considerations

✅ Feed Management

• Google Shopping: Product feeds must be accurate and continuously optimised. Poor data leads to disapprovals or poor auction performance.
• Amazon: PDP quality—images, bullet points, enhanced content—directly impacts ad relevance and organic rank.

✅ Campaign Structuring

• Google: Segment campaigns by product category, margin tier, or geo to control spend and ROI.
• Amazon: Use ASIN-level targeting and negative match types to refine spend efficiency.

✅ Bidding and Budget Management

• Google’s automated bidding (tROAS, tCPA) adapts to real-time signals, but can be constrained by conversion volume or data delay.
• Amazon’s dynamic bidding allows aggressive push for top-selling SKUs, but requires careful margin management.

✅ Attribution and Measurement

• Google Shopping: Typically uses last-click or data-driven attribution models.
• Amazon: Attribution is confined to the Amazon ecosystem, so Google Shopping often influences pre-purchase research, while Amazon finalises the sale.

Final Insights: Which Channel Drives More Sales?

In our experience, Amazon Ads consistently outperform in final conversions for in-market shoppers—especially for products with strong reviews and competitive pricing. However, Google Shopping excels at capturing new audiences who are researching or comparing options. Its broad reach means it’s often the first touchpoint in the journey. Critically, these two platforms serve distinct but complementary purposes. Amazon Ads is best at converting bottom-funnel buyers. Google Shopping is essential for driving discovery and expanding reach outside of Amazon’s walled ecosystem.

‍

Ultimately there is no universal winner—the key to unlocking maximum sales lies in using Google Shopping and Amazon Ads together, but for different reasons:

🔍 Google Shopping: Build brand visibility, expand reach beyond marketplaces, and influence purchase decisions at the consideration stage.
🛒 Amazon Ads: Capitalise on ready-to-buy intent, drive direct conversions, and leverage Amazon’s robust shopping ecosystem.

‍

‍